1976
Of Thee I Sing
1977
Wait Until Dark
Life With Father
South Pacific
1978
The Miracle Worker
Stop the World
Something's Afoot
The King and I
Here Lies Jeremy Troy
1979
The House at Pooh Corner
Bus Stop
Hello, Dolly
1980
The Green Pastures
Sunshine Boys
Carnival
1981
Guys and Dolls
Mary, Mary
Ladies in Retirement
1982
The Good Doctor
The Wizard of Oz
Two by Two
1983
Annie Get Your Gun
I Do, I Do
Fiddler on the Roof
1984
Annie
Everybody Loves Opal
Charlie's Aunt
1985
They're Playing Our Song
On Golden Pond
Bye Bye Birdie
1986
The Five Loves of the Theater
Don't Drink the Water
The Sound of Music
1987
Peter Pan
Deathtrap
Murder at the Howard Johnson's
1988
Arsenic & Old Lace
The Nerd
Funny Girl
1989
The Mousetrap
Godspell
Wally's Café
The Music Man
1990
Natalie Needs a Nightie
Dracula
You're A Good Man Charlie Brown
1991
Anything Goes
The Odd Couple
Steel Magnolias
1992
Adam Shoulda Had Em'
Nunsense
Alice in Wonderland
Diamond Studs: The Life of Jesse James
1993
Blithe Spirit
Guys and Dolls
Harvey
1994
Oliver
Social Security
Noises Off
1995
The Glass Menagerie
Joseph & the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Crimes of the Heart
1996
Little Shop of Horrors
Dear Mrs. Martin
Our Town
1997
The Prisoner of 2nd Avenue
Importance of Being Earnest
Grease!
1998
Meant for this Moment
Night of January 16th
A Stranger Comes to Cottonwood
1999
A Little Night Music
The Nerd
Mark Twain Live
Forever Plaid
2000
To Whom It May Concern
Don't Drink the Water
State Fair
The Wizard of Oz
2001
How the Other Half Loves
The Matchmaker
Smoke on the Mountain
Beehive
2002
Never Too Late
Over the River Through the Woods
G.I. Jukebox
Foreigner
2003
Tommy
Grand Central Station
Sanders Family Christmas
Moon Over Buffalo
2004
Mame
Girls of the Garden Club
Night Must Fall
Noises Off
2005
Diary of Anne Frank
Run for Your Wife
January Thaw
My Fair Lady
2006
Bye Bye Birdie
Yogi
Something's Afoot
2007
Wit
Uninvited
The Secret Garden
The Odd Couple
2008
Confessions of a Dirty Blonde
A Year With Frog & Toad
The Sunshine Boys
Neighbors/Scotter Thomas
2009
Thoroughly Modern Millie
Talley's Folley
Frankenstein
2010
Bad Year for Tomatoes
Hansel & Gretel/Barber of Saville
Annie
2011
Leaving Iowa
Man of La Mancha
Of Mice and Men
Leading Ladies
2012
The Music Man
Ghost of a Chance
A Dog's Life
2013
Pinocchio
Into the Woods
2014
Seven Brides for Seven Brothers
The Creature Creeps
Lend Me a Tenor
2015
My Father's War
70, Girls, 70
Almost Maine
2016
Shrek the Musical
Wait Until Dark
Fox on the Fairway
2017
Grease!
The Mousetrap
Rumors
The Bald Soprano
2018
Young Frankenstein
Arsenic & Old Lace
Baskerville: A Sherlock Holmes Mystery
2019
The Nerd
Once Upon a Mattress
2020
Harvey
2021
My Three Angels
2022
Mary Poppins
The Curious Savage
2023
Clue
Father of the Bride
The Wizard of Oz
2024
12 Incompetent Jurors
The Sound of Music
Charlotte's Web
2025
The Outsider
The Drowsy Chaperone
A Night of Once Acts
Blithe Spirit
2026
Grumpy Old Men: The Musical
Meet Me in St. Louis
The Shawshank Redemption